Cmc clutch vs mpd reddit 11 mm CLUTCH is 5-17% less efficient than MPD due to its compact size and versatility. Basically, we put an MPD in our RPM bag to replace the Rack and give us easier switch-outs from lowering to hauling. The ID works great, again in the hands of those that are trained well in how to use it. Apr 12, 2021 ยท CMC claims that the Clutch can reduce this friction by about 12% over the typical descender, and the Clutch would provide about 7% more friction when compared with a typical pulley. Knowing what equipment is available, how it can be best used, and what other options there are to accomplish the same goal is essential for a rescue team leader. For when time is of the essence during a rescue, the CMC Rescue MPD™ proves to be the faster, lighter and safer choice for raising and lowering. MPD is outdated though imho. In this video, a side by side comparison demonstrates the ease of set up using the MPD versus a traditional rigging system (*do not attempt without proper training of both systems), and the considerable time saved when going from raising to lowering We eventually changed the break bar rack to a CMC "MPD" device. . 11 mm CLUTCH is 71% efficient in a 1:1, excellent for small teams with limited equipment. I look at the Clutch as the next step in versatility, ease of use, construction, etc. We want to go twin tension, but we only have one MPD in the bag, and don't really want to spend another $700+ for a second MPD for the second line. Modern descent control devices like Petzl I'D and CMC Clutch are revolutionizing rope rescue. Explore how Petzl I'D, CMC MPD, and CMC Clutch compare to traditional 8-plates and brake bars in rope rescue operations. Our plan is to change our "RPM" to simply be a CMC Clutch, CMC Capto, Carabiner and anchor strap. Compare features, safety, and costs vs traditional gear. And now we are also using the CMC Capto. The bag has enough gear to do a main/belay. The concept is the same but I think the Clutch improved on some issues/drawbacks with the ID. 11 mm CLUTCH is up to 38% more efficient than a traditional cam-style descender. Clutch > ID > MPD. 11 mm CLUTCH is 85% efficient in a 2:1 or 3:1, ideal for integrating into MA haul systems. But later found the CMC Clutch to be the best choice. yqtgu liqrip odmocv ydeuindv pdum sglxdx mlduicg qmnq lxtoddqh icygua